Kaspersky vs Bitdefender

Kaspersky and Bitdefender are established leaders in the antivirus world, although they may not be as well known to many consumers as providers such as Norton and McAfee. In this comparison, I will give you all the background information you need to know and take a look at the numbers behind each program’s performance and effectiveness against malware.

I will be delving into the important things to consider before purchasing your antivirus software. I will compare the effectiveness of malware protection, PC performance, and the overall usability of the software. The comparable plans will be Kaspersky Total Protection and Bitdefender Premium Security, both excellent antivirus software for a novice or more technically savvy user.

Want the short version? Who wins between Kaspersky and Bitdefender?

Kaspersky Total Security is my winner. It has superb protection against malware and other online threats, with minimal impact on my PC performance. It also has many added features such as an encrypted browser and password manager, plus the setup is simple and easy.

Here’s what I found out when comparing Kaspersky to Bitdefender:

Summary

Kaspersky Total Security

  • Privacy and identity theft protection
  • Encrypted Browser
  • File Protection

Bitdefender Premium Security

  • Multi-layer Ransomware Protection
  • Unlimited and secure VPN
  • Advanced Parental Controls
FeatureKaspersky Total SecurityBitdefender Premium Security
Antivirus and Antispyware
Firewall
Webcam Protection
Password Manager
Anti-Phishing
Ransomware Protection
Banking and Payment Protection
Parental Control
Network Attack Protection
Encrypted Storage
Automatically update apps
VPN
PC Cloud Backup✔ (On PC)✔(50GB)
File Shredder
Performance Optimization
Identity Theft Protection
Run suspicious apps in sandbox

Background

Kaspersky

Kaspersky is one of the world’s largest privately-owned cybersecurity companies, with over 4,000 specialists working on online safety products. It operates in 200 countries and territories around the world and protects 400 million users worldwide. Endpoint security has always been the core of Kaspersky, and the company expects its future growth to be in the enterprise market. Kaspersky is constantly expanding its enterprise portfolio with security solutions and services to provide the best protection. Some experts are wary of Kaspersky due to its alleged links with the Russian government, although the company’s founder recently responded by saying there is no foundation for the claims made against Kaspersky by the U.S. Government.

Bitdefender

Bitdefender is a Romanian cybersecurity company and was founded in 2001. It protects half a billion users worldwide and it also works with government organizations, SMEs and private individuals across 150 countries. Bitdefender employs over 1600 people and is one of the most innovative IT security software vendors in the world today.

Pricing and Compatibility

The price of an antivirus program is one of the top points to consider for most consumers. Antivirus programs are an investment, especially if you opt for a more premium package. Bitdefender and Kaspersky are quite different in their pricing. For Kaspersky Total Security you will pay $99.99 to protect five devices, whereas Bitdefender Premium Security is $149.99 for ten devices. Both of these plans offer protection for a year, after which you can decide whether to renew.

Kaspersky offers a free basic antivirus software to protect against the core threats online, whereas Bitdefender has no free offering. The table below outlines the different packages and prices that both Kaspersky and Bitdefender offer.

Many programs offer discounts for your first year. Kaspersky and Bitdefender are no different. Bitdefender offers $60 off your first year, making Bitdefender Premium Security $89.99. Kaspersky offers a savings of 50%, making your first year of Total Security $49.99.

What happens if you’re not satisfied with your product? Both companies offer a 30-day money-back guarantee if you are not happy with your product. It gives you the peace of mind of being able to test out the software and interface first.

Both Kaspersky and Bitdefender work with all the major operating systems, which include, Windows, MacOS, and Android devices.

Effectiveness against malware

The most important thing about antivirus programs is protection. It’s important to choose one that provides all-round security when using your PC, whether for work or leisure. As digital threats become more and more sophisticated, it’s imperative to choose an antivirus with strong protection.

To find out which one came out on top in terms of protection, I ran a test to check for malware threats in real-time. The next step I took was to download sample malware files from The European Institute for Computer Antivirus Research (EICAR). To decide how well the malware was detected, I turned off real-time detection and ran a full system scan and also a quick scan. The results are in the table below.

Test FileEICAR Sample 1EICAR Sample 2EICAR Sample 3EICAR Sample 4Live Sample 1 (Adware)Live Sample 2 (Trojan)Live Sample 3
(Trojan)
KasperskyBlockedBlockedBlockedBlockedBlockedDetectedDetected
BitdefenderBlockedBlockedBlockedBlockedBlockedBlockedBlocked

As you can see from the table, both Kaspersky and Bitdefender excelled in blocking and detecting the threats.

bitdefender live sample

Both programs blocked all of the EICAR samples. The live samples were also blocked by Bitdefender. For Kaspersky, all live samples were deleted after unlocking and unzipping.

From my tests, both programs detected, blocked, and deleted the samples efficiently.

To see if my results were accurate and to add more depth, I looked at some of the latest test results from some leading independent analysts: AV-Test and AV-Comparatives.

The first from AV Test looks at protection rates against malware attacks, inclusive of web and email threats. During March and April 2020, Bitdefender scored 100%. Kaspersky received a 100% score in March and 99% in April.

Next I looked at AV-Comparatives latest Malware Protection test from September 2019. Bitdefender scored 99.5% and Kaspersky 99.9%.

AV-Comparatives false alarm test is also a useful tool in determining how many false positives occur when the antivirus program flags a non-malware file as malware. This can be extremely irritating for the user, resulting in false notifications and even preventing legitimate programs from running. In this test from September 2019, Bitdefender showed seven false alarms whilst Kaspersky showed zero. 

To sum up, both Kaspersky and Bitdefender score very well in regards to protection rates, both in my own tests and the ones run independently by leading websites. As Kaspersky flagged zero false alarms, it edges out Bitdefender in detection rates.

See also: Common types of Malware explained

Impact on PC Performance

Most antivirus programs are relatively large pieces of software installed on your PC, so they can affect your PC’s performance when running scans in the background. To decipher which one is less impactful on my PC’s performance, I ran a number of tests and captured some data while running both a full scan and a quick scan.

The table below shows my findings for both the full scan and quick scan.

Test FileEICAR Sample 1EICAR Sample 2EICAR Sample 3EICAR Sample 4Live Sample 1 (Adware)Live Sample 2 (Trojan)Live Sample 3
(Trojan)
KasperskyBlockedBlockedBlockedBlockedBlockedDetectedDetected
BitdefenderBlockedBlockedBlockedBlockedBlockedBlockedBlocked

To sum up the findings, a full scan with Kaspersky took 227 minutes while Bitdefender took 110 minutes. However, Kaspersky only took 273 seconds for the quick scan while Bitdefender took 338 seconds.

The table below sums up the impact the scans had on my PC performance.

Test TypeFull Scan Time (minutes)Full Scan Items ScannedQuick Scan CPU Utilization %Quick Scan Memory Utilization %Quick Scan Disk Utilization %Quick Scan Time (seconds)
Kaspersky22721000007173531273
Bitdefender110420000056813577338

The findings in the table show that Bitdefender had lower CPU utilization at 32% when there was no scan running, compared to Kaspersky at 46%. The full scan utilization also showed similar results with Kaspersky recording 100% and Bitdefender 56%.

As with the malware protection test, I took a look at some more independent tests from the AV-Comparatives website to determine if my findings were similar to these benchmarking results. The test run by AV-Comparatives shows how each antivirus impacts on PC performance during eight common tasks:

  • Downloading files
  • Browsing Websites
  • File Copying: First and subsequent run
  • Installing/uninstalling applications
  • Archiving / unarchiving
  • Launching applications: First and subsequent run

Each task is given a rating ranging between very fast and slow. In October 2019 Performance Test, Bitdefender and Kaspersky scored very fast in tests for all common tasks.

Both Kaspersky and Bitdefender are similar in performance and cannot be at all differentiated in AV Comparatives’ results. My own tests indicated Kaspersky was slightly faster and more responsive of the two programs.

Features

As Bitdefender and Kaspersky have similar comparability in protection and performance, let’s take a look at the features both have to offer. Many antivirus programs come with an abundance of features to make them more appealing to potential customers. Below I have outlined the extra features of each program.

Kaspersky Total Security

  • Defends against viruses, ransomware & more
  • Protects without slowing you down
  • Easy to set up and use
  • PC Mac and Mobile
  • Blocks phishing
  • Encrypted browser
  • Safe Kids
  • Password Manager
  • File Protection

Bitdefender Premium Security

  • Unlimited VPN traffic
  • Priority Support
  • Device Optimiser
  • Window, macOS, Android and iOS protection
  • Parental Control
  • Multi-layer ransomware protection
  • Protection against malware, spyware, adware

Both programs offer some interesting features that users would benefit from. Below I have highlighted some key ones that might persuade you into purchasing each program.

Kaspersky

Safe Kids Parental Controls – Includes ‘bad content’ blocker, GPS tracker, and more on PC, Mac & mobile. You will be able to easily manage and regulate your child’s activities online and check reports easily via your account. This is great if you are looking for protection for a family computer that is used frequently by children.

Safe banking – If you often bank online, Kaspersky will launch an encrypted browser to protect online transactions on PC and Mac.

Privacy – Kasperksy’s privacy features are second to none. It stops webcam hijacks and also hides your browsing activity on PC and Mac. Kaspersky also blocks phishing attempts.

Bitdefender 

Unlimited VPN Traffic – Bitdefender Premium VPN protects your online presence by encrypting all internet traffic including your bank info, passwords and downloads. Bitdefender Premium Security includes unlimited encrypted traffic for your Windows, Android, macOS and iOS devices.

Anti-Theft – Bitdefender Premium Security packs effective anti-loss and anti-theft tools for your Windows laptop or tablet, remotely accessible from anywhere in the world via your Bitdefender account.

Multi-layer ransomware protection – Bitdefender’s multi-layered approach against ransomware includes a data-protection layer that safeguards your documents, pictures, videos and music against any kind of ransomware attack.

Sign Up and Installation

If you’re a newbie at antivirus software or tech in general, easy installation is a must. Luckily, most programs are simple to sign up and install and Kaspersky and Bitdefender are no different. Both programs clearly highlight their discounts and price above the ‘Buy Now’ button on their website.

Kaspersky support

Kaspersky greets you with a pop-up window to upgrade to more devices, which is a handy reminder to make sure you all your devices are protected, but could annoy some users.

Bitdefender home page

Both programs have automatic renewal toggled on by default, so if you do not wish to renew the following year, switch this to off to avoid automatic renewal. Both programs only took a few minutes to go from purchase to installation.

How easy is the interface to use?

Both programs’ dashboards are clean and simple. When opening the dashboard for Bitdefender, you will be greeted by a ‘You are safe’ slogan. It also has the usual overview of your device and protection, privacy, and utilities section. There is also a section for you to share your suggestions and things you would like to see in any future updates.

Kaspersky interfaace

Similarly, Kaspersky’s dashboard will give you a green check to let you know that everything is running accordingly. There are also common tools that you may need such as scan, database update, safe money, privacy protection, password manager, backup and restore, and parental control. This makes it really easy to navigate to the right section. The design is fairly simple, with a light grey and green color scheme.

Bitdefender dashboard

Customer Support

Having reliable customer support is important when purchasing antivirus software. Having someone on hand to answer any questions or resolve problems gives you the peace of mind for any future problems that may arise. Below is a brief summary of Kaspersky and Bitdefender’s customer support.

Kaspersky Total Security

Kaspersky technicians are on call via phone between the hours of 7 a.m. and 1 a.m., seven days a week. Customer support is also available via email or online chat. There are also extensive videos, FAQs and other useful information you can find on its website if you do not wish to speak to someone directly.

Bitdefender Premium Security

Bitdefender Premium Security offers an extensive support hub, with many common problems answered on its website or shown through online videos, which is great if you want an easy fix. If this is not doable, you can contact support via email, phone call, online chat, or through the expert community forum. Bitdefender is available to answer any questions 24/7, giving you that peace of mind if something goes wrong.

Conclusion

Kaspersky and Bitdefender rank fairly similarly in terms of protection and performance, with results being difficult to differentiate in my own tests and the independent tests done by AV-Test and AV-Comparatives.

Where they differ is in the false alarm test, with Kaspersky detecting an impressive zero false alarms, compared to Bitdefender’s seven false alarms.

Both offer some great features, however, Kaspersky’s impressive privacy features such as Safe Kids and Safe Banking makes it a worthy winner. Kaspersky also has a lower price point compared to Bitdefender.

Although both are excellent contenders, Kaspersky wins on all-round performance, protection and affordability.

See also: