Best VPN for torrenting according to reddit users

If there’s one thing Redditors love above all else, it’s privacy. Reddit’s design emphasizes anonymity for its users by requiring very little information to sign up. It should come as no surprise, then, that many Redditors, and especially those who torrent, also use and recommend VPNs (Virtual Private Networks). Although there are well over 100 VPNs on the market, Reddit users only recommend a small handful of them.

reddit torrent vpns
Source: Reddit

We poured through several forums popular among Redditors who torrent, looking to answer a simple question: Which is the best VPN for torrenting, according to Reddit users? Redditors have some VPNs they love (and some they hate), but for torrenting, there’s one clear winner.

TL;DR: NordVPN is the most upvoted on Reddit

If you search across Reddit, you’ll likely find different VPNs mentioned here or there. However, the service that gets talked about the most for torrenting is NordVPN.

reddit torrent vpns nordvpn
Source: Reddit

That’s not to say it’s the only VPN service out there currently recommended by Reddit users. Private Internet Access (PIA) and Mullvad also get mentioned rather frequently among Redditors who torrent. However, our analysis of Reddit forums popular among torrent users finds NordVPN mentioned the most often, and with a large number of positive recommendations from current users.

Why choose NordVPN for torrenting?

The service offers over 5500 servers in 60 countries. Any server can technically be used to torrent, yet NordVPN is unique in offering dedicated P2P servers. These servers help maximize download speeds while maintaining an expected level of network security. 

reddit torrent vpns nord
Source: Reddit

NordVPN also offers to shield users against discovery with a strict no-logs policy. None of your online activity through the service is maintained.

Most importantly, NordVPN integrates well with torrent clients to help ensure and maintain your anonymity across torrent networks. The service masks your IP address by connecting you to its secure servers through a private VPN tunnel. It also maintains features, such as a kill switch and DNS leak protection, to ensure your true location doesn’t leak while connected to the VPN.

NordVPN even includes a feature that lets you select specific apps to cover with your kill switch. This will block internet access to the apps you specify (such as a torrent client) if anything goes wrong with your VPN.

reddit torrent vpns nord
Source: Reddit

NordVPN brings together several key technologies that help provide great download speeds for torrenting. As a result, it’s become highly favored among Reddit users who torrent (and who aren’t shy expressing their favor for it, either).

reddit torrent vpns nordvpn
Source: Reddit

That said, NordVPN does have its flaws for torrenting. Our regularly-updated speed tests have found NordVPN isn’t the fastest VPN on the block. However, speeds vary, and you can increase your average speed by using a server closer to your actual location and choosing a less-crowded server

As well, you’ll occasionally see some Redditors criticize larger VPNs like NordVPN for not offering port forwarding. We’ll discuss port forwarding a bit more below. However, note that while port forwarding can increase your download speeds, it also makes your connection less secure. 

NordVPN Coupon

Save 70% with this limited deal on 3 year plans

GET DEAL
Discount applied automatically

I heard NordVPN is engaged in data mining. Is that true?

To dispel those rumors: NordVPN does not mine data, despite false rumors circulating on Reddit. The company defended itself on its blog, while independent research confirmed the company was not involved in nefarious activities with user data. All the same, rumors are hard to kill on Reddit, although many Reddit users are now trying their utmost to ensure that this particular rumor dies.

reddit torrent vpns nordvpn
Source: Reddit

Other VPNs Redditors love for torrenting

NordVPN may be the most talked-about and hotly debated VPN for torrenting, but it’s not the only option. Private Internet Access (PIA), Mullvad, Windscribe, and TorGuard are honorable mentions. We found that when torrent VPN topics come up on Reddit, each of these are often recommended as NordVPN alternatives, and tend to receive positive feedback and upvotes.

Redditors love PIA’s low cost and verified privacy features

Private Internet Access is one of the largest and oldest VPN providers. Alongside NordVPN and ExpressVPN (which is highly-favored for unblocking streaming services), this service has thousands of servers available in dozens of countries.

More specifically, PIA has high-speed servers in 30+ countries, with over 3,300 servers. It also features a strict no-logs policy, AES-256 encryption, DNS leak protection, fast speeds, and unlimited bandwidth. 

The service has been vetted in court twice, verifying that it keeps no logs and fully anonymizes user data.

reddit torrent vpns private internet access pia
Source: Reddit

Thankfully, PIA integrates with popular torrent clients to ensure your anonymity on the network is secure, even if the application or your internet connection fails.

reddit torrent vpns pia private internet access
Source: Reddit

If you absolutely need port forwarding with your VPN option, PIA is a good and popular alternative to NordVPN. The service also provides instructions for how to setup port forwarding while connected to its VPN servers.

Redditors love Mullvad’s speed

Compared to Private Internet Access and NordVPN, Mullvad may look like a small contender. With 400+ servers in just under 40 countries, it doesn’t have as many resources to choose from. However, the company maintains high standards for privacy and security and even utilizes numbered accounts that lack any personally identifying information. Mullvad is also one of the only VPN providers that allow you to pay discreetly with physical cash, reducing your available identity footprint. 

As with the other services, Mullvad has a strict no-logs policy and military-grade encryption standards. Unfortunately, Mullvad lacks a kill switch (which you’ll find with NordVPN or PIA). The company offers some instructions on its website for how to get one, but if you want a complete package, Mullvad may not provide exactly what you need.

reddit torrent vpns mullvad
Source: Reddit

As with PIA, Mullvad also allows port forwarding using its service. The service also offers instructions for port forwarding through its servers.

Redditors love Windscribe’s price and speed

One thing we tend to recommend against (and explain in more detail below) is free VPNs. There are always a few exceptions to the rule, however, and that includes Windscribe. This service has a free and paid option. As you might expect, the free option has data caps: 2GB per month, or 10 GB per month if you give them your email address and other information. 

reddit torrent vpns windscribe
Source: Reddit

Windscribe is also not the most secure option, but it does offer some of the requisite features to protect you while torrenting. It’s regularly mentioned on Reddit by those who torrent, with few negative remarks about it that we could find.

reddit torrent vpns windscribe
Source: Reddit

The service offers a kill switch and port forwarding for those who need to seed while torrenting. If you want an unlimited option, Windscribe offers a low-cost yearly plan, a “Build a Plan” option starting at $1 per month, and the option to purchase a static IP which grants port forwarding. You’ll also have access to all of the Windscribe’s servers and server locations.

Redditors love TorGuard’s features

Torguard does not get mentioned as often as NordVPN or PIA, but when it does, it’s usually posted as an alternative to these. Redditors generally recommend TorGuard for its array of features: a kill switch, strong encryption standards, port-forwarding, a strict no-logs policy, and 3000+ servers in 50 countries.

reddit torrent vpns torguard
Source: Reddit

When this VPN is recommended, it’s often recommended alongside Mullvad.

reddit torrent vpns torguard
Source: Reddit

TorGuard is not the cheapest option available, but the service is often available with discount codes. 

Redditors universally dislike and distrust free VPNs

Alongside anonymity, Reddit users tend to love saving money. As such, the topic of free VPNs pops up every so often. Those new to VPNs tend to ask this question, and with good reason. After all, if there are good paid options for a product, surely there are good free options, as well?

With VPNs, this just isn’t the case.

reddit torrent vpns free vpns
Source: Reddit

Although they can save you money, free VPNs come with notable limitations that make them a poor substitute for a paid option. They’re also a privacy nightmare for torrenting, as one Reddit user noted:

reddit torrent vpns free
Source: Reddit

This user’s experience helps highly a key reason to avoid free VPNs: they tend to lack proper privacy protections.

Alongside this, free VPNs typically have low data caps and poor bandwidth, which makes them unusable for torrenting most things. As well, many free VPNs monetize by collecting and selling user data.

What is port forwarding? Do I need port forwarding to torrent?

As you scour Reddit for advice on torrenting privately and securely, you may run across the term “port forwarding”. Most experienced torrent users on Reddit will assume you know what this means, so you may have a difficult time getting a clear explanation on Reddit’s forums.

In simple terms, port forwarding creates a secure connection between one device and another remote device. For example, you can use port forwarding to remotely connect to a home security camera while you’re away from home. The process is sometimes referred to as calling a phone number using an extension—when you connect to a network remotely, you get to an exact location on that network instead of getting defaulted to a specific location (or port). 

Port forwarding is problematic for torrenting, however, as it bypasses the firewall your VPN service might be using. This makes it easier to discover your true identity on the network. So while you may get faster speeds, port forwarding also reduces your security. As well, VPN firewalls mostly interfere with seeding (sharing) on the network instead of leeching (downloading) from the network.

Nevertheless, some torrent networks will punish you with a speed reduction if you don’t also seed while you download torrents. Depending on the torrent network you plan to use, you may find it necessary to use a VPN service with port forwarding to avoid getting your download speeds reduced.